The Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade has sparked controversy following its launch on November 12, 2026. Despite receiving positive professional reviews, Nintendo’s latest paid upgrade has disappointed many players.
Performance issues, longer loading times and disagreements over Dandori Academy’s content are among the main complaints.
Meanwhile, the considerable difference between professional and user scores highlights the divided reception surrounding this Nintendo Switch 2 Edition.
The Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade divides critics and players
Four days after its release, Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy presents two contrasting reception figures.
On Metacritic, the upgraded edition currently holds a 2.1 user score out of 10, based on 265 ratings.
By comparison, the original Pikmin 4 has an 8.9 user score on the same platform.
Professional reviews, however, paint a considerably different picture.
According to its OpenCritic page, the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition currently holds an average score of 84 out of 100.
Furthermore, 94% of critics recommend the upgraded edition, based on 17 reviews.
These figures illustrate a substantial disagreement between professional critics and users who have submitted ratings.
Nevertheless, the relatively small number of user ratings should be considered when interpreting the wider community’s reception.
Why players are criticizing the Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade
For existing Pikmin 4 owners, Nintendo’s upgrade costs $10 in the United States.
Although the update introduces additional features, several players believe certain aspects of the original experience have become worse.
As detailed by Kotaku, user reviews and community discussions highlight recurring complaints about technical performance and additional content.
The most frequently reported concerns include:
- 30fps limitation: The upgraded edition still targets 30 frames per second instead of offering a 60fps option.
- Framerate stability: Some players report less consistent performance compared with the original version.
- Longer loading times: Certain users have experienced noticeably slower loading after installing the upgrade.
- Reused environments: Much of Dandori Academy reportedly features maps from the original game.
- Content availability: Some Dandori Academy maps are only playable at certain times.
- High-score rewards: Players have expressed disappointment with the incentives for achieving better results.
- Older textures: Despite resolution improvements, some textures appear unchanged.
- Title screen: Some users dislike the prominent Dandori Academy banner displayed on the main screen.
One particularly noticeable complaint concerns loading times.
One review reported that a standard loading sequence increased from approximately six seconds to more than 30 seconds.
However, it is a single measurement rather than a comprehensive technical assessment.
What does Nintendo’s $10 upgrade actually include?
Nintendo introduced the updated edition with a combination of visual improvements, new functionality and additional gameplay challenges.
Existing owners can access these additions by buying the Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade.
The main features announced for this edition include:
- Improved visuals: Higher resolution and increased draw distance.
- Voice commands: A new way to issue instructions to Oatchi.
- Dandori Academy: Additional bonus levels focused on completing challenges.
These additions were central to the original Dandori Academy announcement for Nintendo Switch 2.
However, the upgrade’s reception suggests that visual improvements alone have not satisfied every returning player.
Higher resolution and increased draw distance have received positive feedback, even among users criticizing other aspects.
Nevertheless, concerns about older textures and inconsistent performance continue to influence discussions surrounding the paid upgrade.
Dandori Academy receives mixed feedback
Beyond technical performance, Dandori Academy has become another dividing point between professional reviews and player reactions.
Critics have generally welcomed its demanding challenges, alongside the charm retained from the original Pikmin 4.
However, some players expected more original environments rather than additional challenges built around familiar locations.
Restrictions affecting when certain maps become available have also generated criticism.
Additionally, some users consider the rewards for achieving high scores insufficient.
Professional reviews have not overlooked every limitation either.
Some critics have questioned Dandori Academy’s strict time limits and the absence of additional performance and control options.
In particular, the lack of a 60fps mode and mouse controls has attracted criticism.
Consequently, both audiences share certain concerns despite reaching different conclusions about the overall package.
Not every Pikmin fan agrees with the backlash
Although negative user ratings have attracted attention, criticism of the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition is not unanimous.
Some longtime Pikmin fans believe the negative reaction has become disproportionate to the upgrade’s shortcomings.
Others consider the additional features consistent with what previous Nintendo Switch 2 Edition releases have offered.
From this perspective, the Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade still offers worthwhile additions despite its reported limitations.
However, dissatisfied players continue questioning whether the improvements justify paying another $10 for an existing game.
The disagreement highlights different expectations surrounding paid upgrades for previously released Nintendo titles.
Meanwhile, Nintendo’s wider release schedule continues expanding, as reflected in the Nintendo Switch 2 release calendar for 2026 and 2027.
Nintendo has not addressed the criticism
As of November 16, 2026, Nintendo has not publicly responded to the criticism surrounding the upgraded edition.
Therefore, whether the company intends to address the reported performance problems or other complaints remains unknown.
For now, the contrast between professional recommendations and negative user ratings remains a defining aspect of its launch.
While critics appreciate the additional challenges and visual improvements, dissatisfied players continue questioning the upgrade’s value.
The Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade has consequently reopened discussions about player expectations for paid enhancements on Nintendo’s console.









