Super Smash Bros Was Hard to Explain, Says Sakurai

The Nintendo franchise’s creator recalls the difficulties of communicating an unconventional combat system and explains why originality mattered to its longevity.

Published on  

Cinematic illustration for a Super Smash Bros news article showing an empty Japanese arcade at night, with rows of arcade machines displaying abstract colorful lights, red joysticks, multicolored buttons, red stools and neon lights reflecting on the polished floor.

Super Smash Bros emerged from Masahiro Sakurai’s desire to approach fighting games differently from established arcade franchises. However, communicating that vision proved particularly difficult during the development of the original Nintendo 64 title. Recognizable Nintendo characters made the concept appealing, but its unconventional combat mechanics were considerably harder to explain. More than two decades later, Sakurai has reflected on the challenges of introducing those original ideas.

Why Super Smash Bros was so difficult to explain

During an interview with Japanese outlet Denfamicogamer, Sakurai revisited the creative decisions behind the original fighting game. His comments were translated into English by Nintendo Everything and subsequently covered by GamesRadar+ on November 16, 2026. According to Sakurai, the presence of characters like Mario, Link and Pikachu made its basic premise marketable. Explaining how those characters would actually fight, however, presented an entirely different challenge.

Traditional fighting games already offered an established framework that developers and players could easily recognize. Sakurai instead wanted to introduce mechanics inspired by platforming games, making movement and positioning central to combat. That approach required communicating ideas without relying on familiar examples from other successful fighting franchises. Consequently, even recognizable characters could not completely overcome the difficulties of explaining the game’s underlying design.

How Super Smash Bros changed the rules of fighting games

One of Sakurai’s most important decisions involved reconsidering how players defeat their opponents during a match. Conventional fighting games generally revolve around attacks that gradually reduce an opponent’s remaining health or energy. Smash introduced a different system, where successful attacks increase the damage percentage displayed alongside each character. Instead of depleting a health bar, players must ultimately knock their opponents outside the stage. The fundamental differences between both approaches can be summarized through several gameplay elements:

  • Damage system: Hits increase damage percentages instead of directly reducing a conventional health bar.
  • Victory conditions: Players eliminate opponents by knocking them outside the stage.
  • Positioning: Character placement becomes particularly important throughout each fight.
  • Movement: Platformer-inspired mechanics help define the combat experience.
  • Combat approach: Accumulating damage and creating opportunities for knockouts replace traditional health depletion.

Sakurai believed these mechanics could provide an entertaining experience despite their unfamiliarity to established fighting game audiences. His confidence rested particularly on the relationship between accumulated damage, character movement and positioning during matches. Meanwhile, more conventional fighting games continue developing their own combat systems through releases and subsequent adjustments. One example is Dragon Ball FighterZ and its 2026 balance update.

A conventional Nintendo crossover might not have enjoyed the same longevity

During the interview, Sakurai also considered what might have happened under a more conventional development approach. His hypothetical alternative involved familiar fighting game mechanics, including guarding, regular attacks, special moves and energy depletion. Such a system would have made the project’s central concept easier to communicate using existing genre conventions. Nevertheless, Sakurai questioned whether the original game would have even reached release under those circumstances.

The director believes that familiar characters alone would not necessarily have given the franchise its lasting identity. In his view, a conventional Nintendo crossover could have been perceived as little more than a temporary novelty. Instead, its distinctive mechanics gave the experience characteristics that separated it from other established fighting games. For Sakurai, those creative decisions were important to the series’ ability to endure over time.

Early critics struggled to adjust to Nintendo’s unconventional fighting game

When the original title arrived in 1999, fighting game audiences already had several prominent points of reference. Street Fighter II and Virtua Fighter were particularly influential examples of what players expected from the genre. However, Nintendo’s crossover approached combat through different mechanics, objectives and movement possibilities inspired by platforming games. According to Sakurai, some critics initially struggled to adjust to those differences when reviewing the original release.

That reaction illustrates another complication involved in introducing unfamiliar gameplay systems within an established video game genre. Players and critics can approach new releases with expectations shaped by the games they already understand. Smash challenged those expectations by changing fundamental elements rather than simply introducing different characters or presentation. Its unconventional mechanics consequently became another obstacle when communicating the experience beyond its original development team.

Masahiro Sakurai explains the challenges of pursuing originality

Beyond the franchise itself, Sakurai’s reflections address a broader difficulty involved in developing original video game concepts. Deliberately introducing unfamiliar mechanics can make it harder for developers to communicate their intentions to colleagues. Without established examples, determining the necessary development steps and identifying a clear direction can become particularly challenging. Therefore, originality involves more than simply proposing ideas that distinguish a project from its competitors.

For Sakurai, the development experience demonstrates how difficult it can be to communicate concepts without existing precedents. His reflections also provide insight into the relationship between creative ambition and practical decisions during game production. The director has discussed other challenges facing video game development throughout his career, including emerging technologies. Among his recent observations are Sakurai’s comments about generative AI in game development.

From the Nintendo 64 original to Smash Bros. Ultimate

Developed by HAL Laboratory, the first Super Smash Bros. launched on Nintendo 64 in 1999. Sakurai, who also created Kirby, established a fighting game series built around an unconventional approach to combat. Damage percentages, positioning and knocking opponents off stages became defining characteristics of its gameplay identity. Those fundamental ideas remained part of the franchise as it continued across subsequent generations of Nintendo hardware.

The series’ latest installment, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, arrived on Nintendo Switch in 2018. Almost two decades separated that release from the original game’s debut on Nintendo 64. Sakurai’s recollections now provide additional context for understanding the creative difficulties behind the franchise’s earliest development decisions. According to its creator, Super Smash Bros owes part of its longevity to challenging established genre conventions.

Share it so all your friends hear about it:
X