The GTA 6 user score is exposing an unexpected divide just two days after Rockstar Games released its biggest title yet. Grand Theft Auto VI has achieved an almost perfect critical reception and extraordinary commercial results. However, its audience rating tells a considerably more complicated story, with genuine gameplay complaints competing against a wave of questionable reviews.
As of November 21, 2026, at 20:30 UTC, the PS5 version holds a 5.6 out of 10 user score on Metacritic, based on 68,282 ratings. Meanwhile, professional critics have awarded it 99 out of 100. That enormous difference raises an important question: are players evaluating the same experience as reviewers, or has the public rating become a battleground for unrelated disputes?
Why the GTA 6 user score differs so sharply from critics
Grand Theft Auto VI currently shares Metacritic’s highest critic average with the original 1998 release of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Its PS5 listing shows 152 critic reviews and the classification “Universal Acclaim”. The achievement places Rockstar’s latest open-world adventure in exceptional company, as Battle4Play previously reported when GTA 6 matched Zelda’s historic rating.
Nevertheless, the public response has developed very differently. Eurogamer reported more than 54,000 user ratings earlier on November 21, with approximately 44% classified as negative. The average briefly entered Metacritic’s red category before recovering to its current “Mixed or Average” classification. Consequently, the 5.6 score should be understood as a changing snapshot rather than a definitive verdict.
There is also a fundamental distinction between the two scoring systems. Professional reviews come from established publications, whereas Metacritic does not require users to provide proof of purchase before submitting a rating. As a result, a user average can reflect legitimate experiences alongside submissions from people who have played very little, or potentially nothing at all. Importantly, negative user ratings do not change the game’s 99 critic score.
GTA 6 user score complaints go beyond review bombing
Although suspicious ratings have attracted considerable attention, dismissing every negative opinion would overlook several recurring criticisms. One concerns performance. GTA 6 runs at 30 frames per second on consoles, including PS5 Pro, without a 60fps performance option. Rockstar explained this limitation before launch, citing the processing demands of its detailed world simulation. Our earlier coverage examined why GTA 6 cannot maintain 60fps on PS5 Pro and how Rockstar reduced input lag.
Other complaints focus on the game’s opening hours. Rather than immediately delivering the spectacular criminal activity associated with the franchise, the introduction spends considerable time on domestic routines and household chores. Some players find this slower approach disappointing, particularly after years of anticipation. Others consider it a deliberate attempt to establish the personalities and everyday lives of protagonists Jason and Lucia.
The relationship between those characters has become another dividing point. GTA 6 places substantial emphasis on their personal connection, which represents a different narrative priority from the unrestricted chaos some fans expected. Additionally, discussions mention sexual content and technical bugs. These concerns deserve to be considered separately because they involve different aspects of the experience, from storytelling preferences to measurable performance issues.
How review bombing complicates the GTA 6 user score
Alongside those complaints, numerous zero-out-of-ten submissions concentrate on ideological objections rather than specific gameplay features. Some contain offensive language or provide little indication that their authors have meaningfully experienced the game. This pattern has prompted accusations of review bombing, a term commonly used when large numbers of negative ratings appear intended to influence public perception.
However, the available figures do not establish how many submissions are coordinated or inauthentic. A very low rating is not automatically fraudulent, just as a perfect rating does not necessarily indicate a thoughtful assessment. Some players defending GTA 6 argue that critics of its opening chapters have reached conclusions before exploring the wider game. That argument highlights the difficulty of interpreting ratings collected during the first weekend.
The problem also predates release. Metacritic had already intervened against fake GTA 6 user reviews submitted before launch, removing entries that appeared before consumers could legitimately play the title. That earlier incident provides useful context, although it does not prove that today’s negative ratings belong to the same activity.
Why Zelda has become involved in the ratings dispute
The controversy is no longer limited to Rockstar’s game. According to reports from Push Square and Nintendo Life, some GTA 6 supporters appear to be posting negative ratings for the Nintendo Switch 2 remake of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, released earlier in November. The remake previously held a 9.6 user average, but that figure has since declined. Despite the drop, its reception remains positive across more than 32,000 ratings.
The apparent connection comes from the competition between two exceptionally well-reviewed 2026 releases. However, it is important to distinguish the Switch 2 remake from the original Nintendo 64 version. The original Ocarina of Time shares the 99 critic record with GTA 6, while the newer remake has its own separate ratings. Negative reviews directed at the remake therefore do not alter that historic tie.
Neither Rockstar, Nintendo nor Metacritic has publicly commented on the reported cross-game rating activity. Furthermore, the identities and motivations of individual reviewers have not been independently established. The situation illustrates how online scoreboards can become symbols of rivalry even when the games being compared offer very different experiences.
What GTA 6’s mixed reception means after its record launch
Commercially, there is little indication that the divided user reception has prevented a remarkable debut. According to figures attributed to Take-Two Interactive, GTA 6 accumulated 32.5 million pre-orders and generated $3.79 billion on its first day. Released on November 19 for PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, it has already achieved historic sales results. A PC edition is not yet available.
Still, sales, critic averages and audience scores measure different things. Purchases demonstrate demand, professional reviews summarize editorial assessments, and user ratings capture public reactions through a system that does not verify ownership. None of these measurements can independently establish how satisfied the entire player base is. Moreover, early reviews may disproportionately reflect players with particularly strong opinions.
For anyone considering a purchase, the most useful approach is to examine specific concerns rather than relying exclusively on a single number. Players sensitive to 30fps performance may reach a different conclusion from those primarily interested in Rockstar’s world-building and character-driven storytelling. Similarly, a slow introduction may be a drawback for some audiences and an advantage for others.
The GTA 6 user score could continue changing as more players complete the story and Metacritic receives additional submissions. For now, the contrast between a 99 critic average and a 5.6 audience rating is less a settled judgment on the game’s quality than evidence of how complicated launch-week reception has become. The question is whether that gap will narrow once initial controversy gives way to longer-term player experiences.
Source: Metacritic’s official Grand Theft Auto VI game listing. Figures referenced are from November 21, 2026, at 20:30 UTC.









